Grateful Dead, October 17, 18, and 19, 1972, Fox Theatre, St. Louis, Missouri

A surprise email landed in our inbox a couple weeks ago from Joe Kolbenschlag of Huntersville, NC who shared with us his latest Grateful Dead compilation, Steel Cut Oats Volume V: Spirited in St. Louis. I’ve had a chance to digest Joe’s mix and it is quite a feast. Thanks for sending this our way, Joe, and keep them coming. Enjoy everyone!

Comments below from Joe:

Steel Cut Oats : Volume V : Spirited In St. Louis
Grateful Dead, October 17, 18, and 19, 1972, Fox Theatre, St. Louis, Missouri

After reviewing several shows for a next project, October 1972 seemed ripe for the picking, as we’ve not heard a single note from this extremely fertile period via official release. It’s only a matter of time before the powers that be also draw the same conclusion, and drop us a sweet 3 or 4 disc compilation set - possibly featuring an entire show. I hope to have remedied this temporary oversight by delivering 4 hours of selections from the Fox Theatre run from St. Louis, Missouri - October 17th, 18th, and 19th, 1972. The middle show on the 18th is easily the most recognizable of the 3 - found in many collections, and for good reason - it’s a classic. Excellent ‘72 energy, tight playing, group telepathy, and most important an explosive 2nd set jam that delivers in spades - it is the centerpiece of this collection - Playin’ > Drums > Dark Star > Morning Dew > Playin’ - 64 minutes of blissed-out Fall ‘72 - it’s the first time the band wove multiple songs into the structure of Playin’ In The Band. This sequence is begging for official release.

Each of these shows has its own quirks and characteristics that make them unique in performance, and as actual recordings or ‘sonic journals’ as Bear himself calls them. The first night has its fair share of technical problems during the 1st set - monitors are a huge issue (when aren’t they back then), and it’s clearly a bother to the band more than normal - causing distractions during songs, and followed up with excessive complaints and long breaks after them. The middle show’s recording is heavy on Weir in the mix - which offers the listener a different perspective and appreciation of his playing at this time - his fills throughout add a much deeper flavor than what is normally found, and a pre-cursor to his evolving jazzy style which becomes more prevalent in 1973 and 1974. The final night - another wonderful complete show on its own merit - is marred by more tape hiss than the average tape from ‘72, however, probably carries the most democratic mix of the 3 shows.

These 9 hours of tapes offered a diverse range of aural challenges, including inevitable ‘cuts’ due to their analog nature. Some excellent tracks were automatically thrown out due to this unfortunate circumstance - specifically the Bird Song from 10.18, Black Peter from 10.19 - only 1 of 4 readings from 1972, and an otherwise uber-melt of a Playin’ In The Band from 10.17. Each of these tracks should be considered outside of this compilation as outstanding; however, they were not going to work in the context of my personal selection criteria. After having an opportunity to recently listen to Vault copies of 10.18’s Bird Song (same problematic cut, yet with obviously better sound quality) and 10.17’s Ramble On Rose (missing on all circulating copies), surprises from these shows still exist, and an official release could spring some new material. On a personal side note - any further cuts, blips, or skips that reside on this collection remain ‘as is’ from the original sources found in the db.etree.org directory - surgery was performed only for the purpose of sequencing, and not on any portion of actual music.

I had a riot re-visiting these shows to create this set. Steel Cut Oats #5 illustrates the band’s turn-on-a-dime abilities, and offers a powerful snapshot of the post-Pigpen Grateful Dead as they continued to charge fresh off a highly successful Spring European tour - Pig’s swan song - and a consistent run of several epic shows from August and September. 1972, along with the next two years are held as a watershed period for the Grateful Dead, and I couldn’t agree more. This set truly speaks for itself - on to the music - play it loud. Enjoy.

1. Promised Land (10.18)
2. Brown Eyed Women (10.18)
3. Mexicali Blues (10.17)
4. Tennessee Jed (10.19)
5. Jack Straw (10.18)
6. Bird Song (10.19)
7. Big River (10.18)
8. Cumberland Blues (10.17)
9. Me and My Uncle (10.17)
10. Don’t Ease Me In (10.18)
11. Greatest Story Ever Told (10.19)
12. Deal (10.18)
13. One More Saturday Night (10.18)
14. Casey Jones (10.18)

15. China Cat Sunflower —>
16. I Know You Rider (10.19)
17. Playin’ In The Band —>
18. Drums —>
19. Dark Star —>
20. Morning Dew —>
21. Playin’ In The Band (10.18)
22. Johnny B. Goode (10.17)

23. Big Railroad Blues (10.18)
24. Drums —>
25. The Other One —>
26. He’s Gone —>
27. The Other One (10.19)
28. Comes A Time (10.19)
29. Uncle John’s Band (10.17)
30. Sugar Magnolia (10.17)
31. Not Fade Away —>
32. Goin’ Down The Road Feelin’ Bad —>
33. Not Fade Away (10.19)

Jerry Garcia, lead guitar, vocals
Donna Jean Godchaux, vocals
Keith Godchaux, piano
Bill Kreutzmann, drums
Phil Lesh, bass, vocals
Bob Weir, rhythm guitar, vocals


April 5th, 2010

please send comments to JoeKolby@gmail.com